The Law Commission has published new reforms to overhaul the system for recovering the proceeds of criminal activities.
The reforms, which are the culmination of a Home Office-commissioned review, would enhance enforcement powers and could lead to the recovery of millions of pounds of additional funds from offenders each year.
A “confiscation order” is a court order made personally against a defendant, compelling them to pay back some or all of the benefits from a crime they have committed, so that the proceeds are returned to the public.
While in some cases the system has been able to recover proceeds and support victims, there is strong consensus that the current regime is inefficient, complex and ineffective – with weak enforcement mechanisms restricting its ability to consistently recover criminal funds.
The Law Commission’s new reforms would bolster the current system, by giving courts more powers to enforce confiscation orders and seize offenders’ assets, limiting unrealistic orders that can never be paid back, and speeding up confiscation proceedings – allowing victims to receive compensation more quickly.
The Commission estimates that reforming the current confiscation regime could lead to an extra £8 million in funds being retrieved from criminals in England and Wales every year, helping to return more money to the public.
What is being proposed?
- Accelerate confiscation proceedings by establishing strict timetables for hearings, which take effect immediately after the defendant has been sentenced for their crime.
- Give courts the power to impose “contingent enforcement orders” at the time that a confiscation order is made, meaning that if a defendant does not pay back the proceeds of a crime within a set time, assets – including property or funds in a bank account – could instead be taken to recover the proceeds of crime.
- Strengthen “restraint orders”, which can be imposed by a court to stop a defendant from protecting funds or assets that might later be involved in confiscation proceedings. Place the “risk of dissipation” test – the test currently used by courts to judge whether to use this order – on a statutory footing, and clarify what could trigger the use of these orders.
- Strengthen law enforcement agencies’ responses, through better police training and a national asset management strategy.
- Update the provisions that factor in a defendant’s “criminal lifestyle”, when assessing their benefit from crime. Confiscation from defendants deemed to have a criminal lifestyle will also include gains from their wider criminal conduct. We recommend that a defendant would have to commit fewer offences to be deemed to have a criminal lifestyle.
- Give greater consideration to the defendant’s ability to pay, so that enforcement can be more effective. Defendants will be obligated to provide clearer and more detailed evidence of their financial position if they claim to be unable to pay their order.
- Create more flexible tools to ensure better enforcement. Give judges the power to adjust the funds that must be paid back by a defendant, depending on their personal circumstances. This would avoid situations where there is no realistic prospect of recovering the full amount of the confiscation order.
- Set out a clear statutory objective to govern the new confiscation regime – namely, to deprive defendants of their benefit from criminal conduct. This would provide clarity on the purpose of the regime and move away from any prior emphasis on “punishment”.
When will these reforms come into force?
The Law Commission is working with the Office of Parliamentary Counsel to produce a draft bill which they aim to publish in 2023. It will then depend on the government to decide its legislative priorities and take steps to bring the bill into law.
How can we help?
Here at Broadbent’s Solicitors, we keep up to date with any changes in legislation and case law so that you don’t have too. If you would like to discuss any aspect of your case, or are in need of a criminal solicitor, please give us a call on Alfreton: 01773 832 511, Derby: 01332 369 090 and Heanor: 01773 769 891. Additionally, you can complete our online contact form where a member of our team will be in touch shortly.
Image credit: “Money on my mind” by jo.sau is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
